Lenny & Larry's built their empire on one product: The Complete Cookie. A massive, 16-ounce protein cookie that became a gym bag staple across America. With over 90,000 monthly searches, they remain one of the most recognized names in the protein snack space.
But here's the thing — in 2026, they've expanded well beyond cookies into protein bars, brownies, and cookie-fied bars. Are any of them worth your money? Let's dig in.
Here's what you're getting per Complete Cookie-fied Bar (45g):
And per Complete Cookie (full cookie, 113g):
Let's be honest: the Complete Cookie's macros are rough. 420 calories and 26g of sugar for 16g of protein is not a great ratio. The Cookie-fied Bar is much better — 200 calories for 16g of protein is respectable, though the 9g of sugar is still above average for the protein bar category.
Lenny & Larry's uses a plant-based protein blend of pea protein, wheat protein, and rice protein. All products are vegan-certified, which is a major differentiator. The combination of pea + rice provides a complete amino acid profile.
However, the inclusion of wheat protein means these are not gluten-free. If you need a gluten-free vegan option, check our gluten-free bars list.
Here's what's in a Lenny & Larry's Cookie-fied Bar (Chocolate Chip):
Brown Rice Syrup is essentially liquid sugar with a "natural" label. It has a higher glycemic index than regular sugar. Combined with cane sugar and chocolate chips, this bar has multiple sugar sources.
Palm Oil makes another appearance. It's cheap, functional, and ubiquitous — but never a positive on a nutrition label.
Enriched Flour as the first ingredient tells you a lot. This is a cookie that happens to have protein added — not a protein bar that happens to taste like a cookie. There's a difference.
Cookie-fied Bars:
Complete Cookies:
The flavor variety is solid, especially for the cookies. The Cookie-fied Bar line is newer and has fewer options, but they're expanding.
The Complete Cookie tastes like an actual bakery cookie — soft, chewy, and genuinely enjoyable. If you handed someone a Chocolate Chip Complete Cookie without context, they might not guess it's a "protein" product. That's both the appeal and the problem: it tastes like a cookie because it basically is one, with protein powder mixed in.
The Cookie-fied Bars are denser and more bar-like. They have a cookie dough texture with chocolate chips throughout. Taste is above average but not as impressive as the full cookies.
Cookie-fied Bars retail for about $14.99 for a 9-pack ($1.67/bar). Complete Cookies run $2.00–$2.50 each. Both are affordable compared to premium protein bars, but when you factor in the sugar-to-protein ratio, the value proposition weakens.
They're not ideal for anyone watching sugar intake, keto/low-carb dieters, gluten-sensitive individuals, or anyone looking for optimal protein-to-calorie ratios.
Both are plant-based, but the similarities end there. LyfeFuel's Essential Nutrition Bar delivers 12g protein with only 4g sugar, 11g prebiotic fiber, and 28+ superfoods — all in 220 calories. Lenny & Larry's Cookie delivers 16g protein but with 26g sugar and 420 calories. LyfeFuel is the nutrition-first choice; Lenny & Larry's is the taste-first choice.
Lenny & Larry's earns points for taste, vegan certification, and brand recognition. But the nutritional profile — especially the Complete Cookie's 420 calories and 26g sugar — puts them near the bottom of the protein snack rankings. The Cookie-fied Bar is a step in the right direction with better macros, but the sugar and ingredients still lag behind cleaner competitors. If you just want a vegan cookie that happens to have some protein, Lenny & Larry's delivers. If you want actual sports nutrition, look elsewhere.
Unearth the cleanest protein bars you can buy right now. (Some might even have superfoods)
Read MoreAt Protein Bar, we’re committed to helping you look and feel your best, which starts by raising the bar (pun intended) in the nutrition industry. We're currently in stealth mode, but you can join our waiting list to receive exclusive access to new products and become a beta tester!
